How to Build a Strong Email List Despite Canada’s Anti-Spam Laws

If you’re a small business owner in Canada, you’ve likely heard of Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL). Introduced in 2014, CASL was designed to protect Canadians from unwanted commercial electronic messages. While its intentions are noble, CASL has caused a lot of confusion (and even fear) among entrepreneurs trying to build legitimate email lists.

But here’s the good news: you absolutely can build a strong, thriving email list in Canada without running into legal troubles. You just need to do it the right way, with transparency, consent, and value.

Let’s break it down with real, actionable strategies.

Understand the Core CASL Requirements

Before diving into tactics, make sure you understand what CASL requires. There are three pillars of compliance:

• Consent: You must have either express or implied consent to send commercial emails.
• Identification: You must clearly identify yourself (your business name and contact info) in every message.
• Unsubscribe Mechanism: Every email must include a working unsubscribe option that is easy to use.

🔍 Express Consent means the user explicitly agreed (for example, checked a box or filled out a form).

🕒 Implied Consent covers cases like existing customer relationships or someone giving you a business card at an event.

Pro tip: Express consent never expires. Implied consent does.

Offer a Compelling Lead Magnet

To encourage people to willingly opt in, you need to give them a reason. This is where lead magnets shine.

Some effective options:

• A free downloadable guide or checklist (for example, “10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Contractor”)
• A discount code or free shipping offer
• Access to a webinar, tutorial, or industry insights
• Entry into a giveaway or contest (with clear consent wording)

📌 Always pair your lead magnet with a clear consent checkbox that isn’t pre-ticked, stating they agree to receive marketing emails.

Use CASL-Compliant Forms and Language

When designing your sign-up form, clarity is king. Avoid fine print or sneaky tactics.

Include:

• A brief description of what they’re signing up for (for example, “Weekly small business tips & promotions”)
• A clear consent statement
• Your business name and contact information
• An easy unsubscribe process (in all future emails)

✅ Example consent statement:
"By entering your email, you agree to receive occasional updates and promotions from ABC Business. You can unsubscribe at any time."

Leverage Your Existing Relationships (Implied Consent)

If someone:

• Has bought from you in the last two years
• Has made an inquiry about your services in the past six months
• Has handed you a business card at an event (and didn't say “don’t email me”)

…you likely have implied consent.

💡 Best practice: Use this window to send an engaging, value-filled email asking them to confirm their subscription for ongoing updates. That way, you convert implied into express consent.

Run a Re-Engagement Campaign (the Right Way)

Got old contacts lingering in your database? Don’t just blast them with promo emails. Instead, send a one-time consent request email.

Structure it like this:

• Subject: “We’d love to stay in touch (but only if you say yes)”
• Body: Remind them how you connected
• Include a prominent opt-in link
• Be transparent about what they’ll receive

🚫 Do not continue emailing if they don’t respond or click the opt-in.

Avoid Purchased or Scraped Email Lists

Buying email lists is not only against CASL, but also a waste of time and money. These people didn’t give you permission, so your messages will likely be ignored or marked as spam, hurting your sender reputation.

Instead, focus on growing organically with targeted content and honest value exchange.

Segment and Personalize for Higher Engagement

When people trust you with their inbox, treat it like sacred ground.

• Segment your list by interests, geography, purchase history, and other relevant     traits
• Send relevant, personalized content (use names, tailor offers)
• Keep emails brief, helpful, and human

📊 Why it matters: The more relevant your emails, the higher your open and click-through rates. That means your subscribers are more likely to remain engaged.

Keep Records of Consent

CASL requires that you be able to prove consent. Use an email marketing platform (like Mailchimp, Kit, or Klaviyo) that:

• Captures the date, time, and source of sign-up
• Logs each opt-in action
• Tracks unsubscribes and preferences

🧾 If you ever face a compliance audit, this paper trail is your best friend.

Use Double Opt-In for Extra Safety

Double opt-in means a user receives a confirmation email before being officially added to your list. While not required under CASL, it is highly recommended.

Why?

• It confirms the email is valid
• It proves they truly intended to subscribe
• It builds trust and sets the tone for transparent communication

Respect the Unsubscribe

Never try to hide the unsubscribe link or make it hard to use. CASL requires:

• That the unsubscribe link be clear and functional for at least 60 days after the message is sent
• That unsubscribe requests be honoured within 10 business days

👋 Don’t take unsubscribes personally. They help keep your list healthy and engaged.

The Bottom Line

Building an email list in Canada isn’t about “tricking” people. It is about earning trust.

If you focus on:

• Delivering value
• Being transparent about your intentions
• Respecting the law and your audience

…you’ll build a high-quality list of subscribers who actually want to hear from you. And that’s the kind of list that drives real business results.

‍